Every Kenyan carbon credit carries a vintage, and every credit is exposed to permanence risk. The vintage tells a buyer which year the reduction or removal took place. Permanence asks whether the carbon will stay stored. Neither question answers the whole matter, but a buyer who skips either one can end up holding units that do not match the claim in their sustainability report.
What Vintage Means
A credit's vintage is the year in which the reduction or removal it represents occurred. That is not always the year the credit reaches the market. Burn Manufacturing's Kenya cookstove project (VCS5642) issued 52,405 tCO2e of vintage 2025 credits in July 2026. Those credits describe activity in 2025, even though they were issued and offered in 2026.
The vintage matters for two reasons. The first is the claim. The year of reduction should fall within the period you plan to report, and a buyer should not assume that an older vintage will satisfy a newer disclosure standard. The second is price. Price depends on the methodology, the quality of verification, the vintage and the co-benefits, so two credits from the same country can trade very differently. Our due diligence checklist explains how to confirm the vintage on the registry.
What Permanence Means
A credit represents carbon that has been kept out of the atmosphere, and permanence is the question of whether it stays out. Carbon can be lost again. Forests face fire, drought, illegal logging and land conversion. Carbon in soil can be released when land returns to ploughing or when drought kills the ground cover. Mangrove carbon is exposed to storms, die-off and illegal cutting. Agroforestry projects face a quieter version of the same problem when trees die or are cut after credits have been issued.
The Buffer Pool
The main tool for managing reversal risk is the buffer pool. A share of issued credits is held back to cover losses if the carbon is released later. Because part of the issuance is withheld, the credits a buyer can actually retire may be fewer than the project's gross carbon gain. Buyers should ask how large the buffer is, what triggers its use, how it is managed over the life of the project, and whether monitoring continues after the crediting period ends.
Vintage and Permanence Together
The two questions interact. An older vintage has had more years in which a forest could be cleared, soil could be disturbed or a stand of trees could die. A recent vintage has a shorter monitoring history behind it. Neither is automatically safer. What matters is whether the verification reports cover the years in question and whether the project has a clear plan for reversal events.
Check the Registry Before the Contract
Both questions can be checked on the public registry. Find the serial numbers of the units on offer, confirm the project ID and vintage, and check whether the units are marked as retired. Retirement removes a unit from circulation so that nobody can sell or claim it again. A unit that is still listed as issued and not yet retired is the one a buyer can retire in their own name, so confirm that status before any payment is made.
Issued Units or Forward Purchases
Credits can be bought as already issued units or as a forward purchase of future issuance. Issued units are simpler, because the vintage and volume are already known. A forward deal can support a project earlier, but the buyer carries the risk that the volume arrives late or smaller than planned. Whichever route you choose, the contract should state the vintage and quantity, what happens if credits are not issued, and how the seller will handle any reversal or invalidation of units. Have your legal adviser review the agreement.
Questions to Put to the Seller
- Which vintage years are on offer, and does each one fall within the period you plan to claim?
- How large is the buffer pool, and has any of it been drawn on so far?
- When was the most recent verification, and what did it find?
- What monitoring will continue after the crediting period ends?
- Who bears the cost if a unit is invalidated after sale?
For project-specific detail, see our notes on soil carbon credits, blue carbon in Kenya and agroforestry measurement, where permanence risk takes a different form.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between vintage and issuance date? The vintage is the year the reduction or removal took place. The issuance date is when the registry created the units. The two are not always the same year.
Does a buffer pool make a credit risk-free? No. A buffer reduces the chance that a reversal leaves a buyer without the carbon they paid for, but it does not remove that chance. Check how the buffer is sized and managed.
Can I use an older vintage in a new report? Only if it fits the period and standard you are reporting against. Do not assume an older vintage will meet a newer disclosure requirement, and check the point with your auditor or adviser.
