A carbon credit can be genuine and the claim built on it can still be misleading. The gap usually opens in the wording: a unit that was retired for one year gets described as if it covers every year, or a forest project is called a removal when it is really an avoidance credit. Before a company repeats a Kenyan carbon claim in a report, an advert or a product label, it should be able to show what the claim rests on.
Red Flag 1: A Vague Claim About What the Credit Does
Phrases such as "carbon neutral", "climate positive" or "we protect the forest" say a great deal in a few words. Ask what exactly the credit pays for. An avoidance credit pays for emissions that did not happen against a baseline. A removal credit pays for carbon that was stored. Neither is wrong, but they support different sentences. If the claim does not say which kind of unit was bought, it is not yet specific enough to publish.
Red Flag 2: No Project ID or Serial Numbers
A real credit sits in a public registry with a project identifier and a serial range. A seller who cannot give those numbers, or who offers a certificate instead, has not shown that the units exist. Ask for the project ID and the serial range, then find them in the registry. Check that the project name, country, methodology and vintage match what the seller described.
Red Flag 3: Retirement Is Missing or Unclear
A credit that is still available for sale can be sold again, so a claim is only as strong as the retirement behind it. The units should be retired in the buyer's name, or in a name the buyer can show it controls, and the registry should record the retirement. Our guide to registry retirement explains what to look for.
Red Flag 4: Vintage and Claim Period Do Not Match
A claim that covers emissions from this year needs units from a matching vintage, or a clear explanation of why an older vintage is used. A 2019 credit used to offset 2025 emissions may be accepted by some buyers and rejected by others, so the wording should say which year the unit represents. The vintage and permanence guide sets out the questions to ask.
Red Flag 5: Possible Double Counting
The same tonne of carbon should not be claimed by two parties. This can happen when a project sells units to a company and the host country also counts the reduction against its own target. Under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, the host country adjusts its reporting to avoid this, and the buyer should ask whether a corresponding adjustment applies. Our explainer on Article 6 and Kenya sets out the basics.
Red Flag 6: Community and Co-benefit Claims Without Evidence
Water, jobs, biodiversity and benefit sharing are real parts of many Kenyan projects, but a claim about them needs evidence. If a company says a project pays local communities, it should be able to name the arrangement and show the payments or the agreement. Our guide to benefit sharing lists what to ask for.
Red Flag 7: Pressure to Publish Before the Checks
A seller who needs a decision within days, or who asks the buyer to announce a purchase before the registry transfer is complete, is asking the buyer to take the risk. Publication should follow verification, not come before it.
How to Test a Claim Before You Repeat It
Work through the claim in this order:
- Write the claim in one sentence that names the unit type, the project, the vintage and the quantity.
- Find the project ID and serial range in the registry and confirm they match the seller's description.
- Check the retirement record and the name it is held in.
- Confirm whether a corresponding adjustment applies, and state the answer in the claim.
- Keep the evidence on file so the claim can be defended if a reviewer asks.
Wording That Holds Up Better
Specific wording is harder to attack. "We retired [quantity] tonnes of verified removal credits from a named Kenyan project, vintage [year], with the registry serial range on file" can be checked line by line. "Our operations are carbon neutral" cannot. The UK Competition and Markets Authority's Green Claims Code asks that environmental claims be clear, accurate, complete and substantiated, and that comparisons are fair. Those principles are a sound test for any Kenyan carbon claim, whatever the market it is published in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a registry certificate enough? A certificate is a starting point. Confirm the project ID, serial range and retirement in the registry itself, because a document can be copied or out of date.
Can a company say it is carbon neutral because it bought credits? The answer depends on the claim and the standard it relies on. A broad statement needs a clear basis, and many buyers prefer to describe the credits they retired rather than the company as a whole. Our note on scope 3 claims covers the wording that corporate buyers can use.
For a full checklist before you buy, see our due diligence guide for buyers. The same questions apply before you publish.